Tropical Aquarium

The Canister Filter - Any Use in a Saltwater Aquarium

The canister filter has been in use for decades. Freshwater aquarists were the first to make use of them and they still do. Then along came the marine aquarium and the canister filter was employed to support those to. Canister filters have been around for so long that they are now very dependable and failures are rare.

Aquarium filtration techniques have progressed considerably in the last decade or so. Aquarists strive to make their reef aquariums dependant on natural filtration as far as possible. The use of 'live' rock is the major example. This rock can support the reef aquarium wonderfully, provided it is of sufficient quality and in sufficient quantity, and its capabilities are not abused by the aquarist. Live rock is probably the number one filtration method in use nowadays, in reef aquariums anyway. Another example of filtration is the DSB (deep sand bed) where natural methods provide support.

So what of the canister filter? With all these modern techniques perhaps the need for a canister filter is gone. Well, no it isn’t.

A canister filter can be used to house activated carbon, or filter pads or wool, to assist in keeping the seawater pollutant clear and dirt free. Some aquarists have put chunks (around ½" to 1? square) of live rock in the canister and report that the life within the canister is quite surprising - tube worms, tiny shrimps etc.

However, is the canister filter finished as far as a prime biological support function is concerned? No, it isn’t, is the answer (in my view). It is not the number one recommended marine biological filtration method nowadays, and rightly so. There are occasions though where the use of a canister filter is, what shall we say - convenient.

Live rock is very expensive, and there is little point in deciding to filter with it if sufficient quantity is not obtained. There are other decorative and marine suitable rocks that have no filtration capability, but are available at a far lower price. So the aquarist who finds the cost of live rock prohibitive is still able to consider a marine aquarium. Decorate with low cost rockwork and filter with a canister filter. There isn’t any need for a sump, another cost reduction.

I can nearly feel the hackles rising on some marine aquarists! But lets consider it further.

The low budget aquarist should, if finances allow, obtain two canister filters, though this is not absolutely necessary - canister filters are reliable as stated. One acts as a back up for the other. The compartments inside should contain coarse and fine filter material (the coarse before the fine). Following the filter material, and last in line, should come the biological media. This is easily obtainable and not too pricey. Sintered glass media is good, but there are others.

The canister filter is cleaned at least every four weeks, or as experience dictates. The coarse/fine filter material must be kept free flowing and the biological media protected from dirt. With two canisters, this can be achieved by cleaning one at two weeks, the other at four weeks, the first at six weeks etc. The biological media is not cleaned, just the coarse and fine filter materials. It goes without saying that the canister filters should have the correct capacity for the aquarium size they are to support.

Ah, I hear the question coming up! But canister filters are just nitrate factories aren’t they? Nitrate in excess is one thing the marine aquarium doesn’t need.

Up to a point that is correct. A canister filter is a nitrate factory. But the production of nitrate is not exclusive to the canister, it is produced by any biological filtration system. Another filtration system will produce the same amount of nitrate as the canister with the same amount of ammonia to start with. It is the nitrogen cycle, the natural breakdown of toxics. There is a difference however. The canister filter is having oxygenated water pumped through it, which means that the nitrogen cycle can only progress as far as the production of nitrate. Live rock, for example, will hopefully complete the full nitrogen cycle, breaking down the nitrate into gas that is released from the aquarium. Routine seawater changes are recommended for all aquariums. Where a canister filter is in use (for biological purposes) the seawater change must be completed as it is one of the methods for reducing nitrate. The aquarist using a canister can consider completing the nitrogen cycle by other means. A denitrator will remove nitrate efficiently, so that is an option. Sulphur denitrators are the best option (in my opinion).

Now things have become more complicated again. If denitrators are to be considered then, coupled with the cost of non-live decorative rock, and the canister filter(s), plus the bio media, the cost is rising. The option for a canister filter seems only sensible when a smallish aquarium is obtained (for example, seawater changes are more manageable and less costly). Larger aquariums seem better with live rock even though the overall cost is high.

This is not a recommendation for canister filters over other filtration methods. It is my opinion that live rock, coupled with a DSB in a sump, is a very good filtration option. However, for a smallish aquarium where water changes are not a problem and the bio-load is not particularly heavy, the canister filter remains a viable biological support possibility. The aquarist should, of course, cost the options very carefully, and use live rock where possible.

About the Author

Peter Cunningham and John Cunningham between them have been keeping saltwater aquariums for over 35 years. Check out their Aquarists Online website if you are interested in learning more about the saltwater aquarium hobby.

Reef Aquarium Artificial Coral Decor, Saltwater Fish Only with Live Rock setup Reef Tank FOWLR

wall mural decor graphic vinyl tropical fish aquarium $234.88

Hosting + exclusive USE of Aquarium Decor .com BLOG $104.34

TRAY GARDEN w/ Fish Bowl Aquarium tank Home Decor,Gift $73.07

TRAY GARDEN w/ Fish Bowl Aquarium tank Home Decor,Gift $73.07

TRAY GARDEN w/ Fish Bowl Aquarium tank Home Decor,Gift $73.07

Aquarium Ammolite Decor Make your Fish Happy 83x44mm $73.06

Monaco AQUARIUM POSTER.Home Decor.Art Deco Marine.Sea 3 $52.20

HUGE 30 LOT PLASTIC AQUARIUM PLANTS DECOR NEW LIFE-LIKE $52.14

4 Aquarium Plastic Tree 7" SET - plants ornament Decor $41.75

5 Aquarium Plastic Tree 5" SET - plants ornament Decor $40.70

Le decor de l'aquarium : Tout le paysage de l'aquarium $40.16

VTG SEAHORSE FISH TANK AQUARIUM FIGURINE ORNAMENT DECOR $39.67

Monaco AQUARIUM POSTER.Home Decor.Art Deco Marine.Sea 3 $39.67

5 Aquarium Plastic Tree 3" SET - plants ornament Decor $36.53

Fresh & Salt Water Saltwater Aquarium Fish Tank Decor * $35.08

OCEAN STAR- SMOOTH BARK TREE STUMP LARGE AQUARIUM DECOR $34.44

AQUARIUM ROCKS FISH TANK DECOR 25/LBS BOX APACHE GREEN $33.40

AQUARIUM ROCKS FISH TANK DECOR 25/LBS BOX APACHE GREEN $32.36

AQUARIUM ROCKS FISH TANK DECOR 25/LBS BOX WHITE QUARTZ $32.36

AQUARIUM ROCKS FISH TANK DECOR 25/LBS BOX EBONY CRYST $32.36

AQUARIUM DECORATION OCEAN SHELLS DECOR SHELL LOT LARGE $31.31

20LED AQUARIUM MOON LIGHTING FISH TANK DECOR SALT FRESH $26.09

Monaco AQUARIUM POSTER.Home Decor.Art Deco Marine.Sea 3 $25.05

Aquarium Fish Tank Decor GREEK ROMAN Ruins 3pc Set EUC $23.49

Aquatic Coral Cavern NEPTUNE GATE Fish Aquarium Decor $23.48

Aquatic Coral Cavern TURTLE COVE Fish Aquarium Decor $23.48

Aquatic Coral Cavern ZEN GARDEN Fish Aquarium Decor $23.48

LOT 7 HUGE PLASTIC AQUARIUM PLANTS DECOR NEW LIFE-LIKE $22.91

3x Flame Moss PAD - Live aquarium plant Decor Tropical $22.44

7-9" barnacle cluster fish aquarium home decor $20.87

DIY20 LED AQUARIUM MOONLIGHT FISH TANK LIGHTING DECOR $20.87

FLORIDA CORAL,8.75" TALL,X3.75" AQUARIUM DECOR,CARRIBE $20.87

LIVING AQUARIUM ANIMATED LAMP FUN HOME DECOR NEW IN BOX $20.83

LIVING AQUARIUM ANIMATED LAMP FUN HOME DECOR NEW IN BOX $20.83

Barnacle cluster free Black sea fan aquarium decor B $19.34

Beach Seahell Mix BULK 4lb Real Home Decor Aquarium WOW $18.78

Beach Seahell Mix BULK 4lb Real Home Decor Aquarium WOW $18.78

Beach Seahell Mix BULK 4lb Real Home Decor Aquarium WOW $18.78

Beach Seahell Mix BULK 4lb Real Home Decor Aquarium WOW $18.78

Aquatic Coral Cavern HAUNTED ISLE Fish Aquarium Decor $18.26

Green Plastic Plants Ornament Decor for Aquarium Tank $18.16

Green Plastic Plants Ornament Decor for Aquarium Tank $18.16

Colorful Marble Rock Mix Decor Aquarium 4lbs BULK WOW $17.74

Colorful Marble Rock Mix Decor Aquarium 4lbs BULK WOW $17.74

LOT 5 HUGE PLASTIC AQUARIUM PLANTS DECOR NEW LIFE-LIKE $17.69

Green Plastic Plants Ornament Decor for Aquarium Tank $18.16

Epave Plante eau Aquarium Ornement Décor Poisson Tank $17.44

Aquarium Plastic Plants Grass Decor for Fish Tank $16.87

5* Ornament Plant Decor Tank Grass Aquarium Decoration $16.69

5* Ornament Plant Decor Tank Grass Aquarium Decoration $16.69

Epave Plante eau Aquarium Ornement Décor Poisson Tank $16.10

Epave Plante eau Aquarium Ornement Décor Poisson Tank $16.10

Green Plastic Plants Ornament Decor for Aquarium Tank $16.12

Green Plastic Plants Ornament Decor for Aquarium Tank $16.11

Green Plastic Plants Ornament Decor for Aquarium Tank $16.11

Green Plastic Plants Ornament Decor for Aquarium Tank $16.06

Skeleton Sailor Ornament Decoration Decor for Aquarium $15.99

Half Shipwreck Aquarium Ornament Decor for Fish Tank $15.99

Set of Shipwrecks Ornament Decoration Decor f Aquarium $15.99

Wrack Water Plant Aquarium Ornament Decor For Fish Tank $15.99

Wrack Water Plant Aquarium Ornament Decor For Fish Tank $15.99

Skeleton Sailor Ornament Decoration Decor for Aquarium $16.22

Vividly Plastic Grass Plants Fish Tank Aquarium Decor $15.91

Set of Shipwrecks Ornament Decoration Decor f Aquarium $16.22

Wrack Water Plant Aquarium Ornament Decor For Fish Tank $16.22

Half Shipwreck Aquarium Ornament Decor for Fish Tank $16.22

Wrack Water Plant Aquarium Ornament Decor For Fish Tank $16.22

PRO ECOLOGY DON'T POLLUTE AQUARIUM DECOR GOODWEEK TIRE $15.86

Aquarium Plastic Plants Grass Decor for Fish Tank $15.79

Aquarium Plastic Plants Grass Decor for Fish Tank $15.79

Aquarium Plastic Plants Grass Decor for Fish Tank $15.79

Monaco AQUARIUM POSTER.Home Decor.Art Deco Marine.Sea 3 $15.66

Windelov fern +Driftwood(M)- Live aquarium plant Decor $15.61

Box Crab 5" x 2 5/8 in. Taxidermy Aquarium Decor $15.61

Vividly Plastic Grass Plants Fish Tank Aquarium Decor $15.91

Goldfish Sunshade Float With Aquarium $24.99 Make splash time fun with this adorable Sun Smart inflatable gold fish....

Aquarium Jolee's Boutique Le Grande Dimensional Sticker SPJBLG-218 $7.48 EK SUCCESS-JOLEE'S Boutique Le Grande Dimensional Stickers. Dimensional and multi media stickers designed by the industries most creative minds. Made of metal; wire; foam; paper; wood; sand; shells; denim and/or more! This package contains one 7x3in sheet. Size; media used; shape; color and number of sticker per package varies by design....

Aquarium Paper Bliss Adhesive Embellishments BLISS-26971 $5.79 WESTRIM-Paper Bliss Adhesive Embellishments are just like stickers only more detail! Sheet size: 4x6-1/2in. Features acid free cardstock paper....

Aquarium décors et plantes $11.95 ...